AI copyright: Current regulations and their effects 2024

The increasing importance of artificial intelligence (AI) raises many legal issues, particularly in the area of copyright law. AI can now create works of art, write texts and compose music. But who owns these creative works? In this article, we look at the current regulations on AI copyright and their effects on various industries.

‍

What is AI copyright?

AI copyright deals with the question of whether and to what extent works created by artificial intelligence are protected by copyright. Traditionally, copyrights are granted to natural persons who have created works through their creative activity. But when it comes to AI-generated works, the question is who can be considered the author: the AI itself, the programmer or the user of the AI?

‍

Overview of current regulations

There are currently no uniform international regulations on AI copyright. Legislation varies greatly from country to country. Here are some key regulations and approaches from different parts of the world:

• EU law: In the European Union, copyright is currently reserved only to natural persons. This means that works created by AI are generally not protected by copyright.
• US law: Similar to the EU, US copyright only recognizes natural persons as authors. However, there is discussion about how AI-generated works should be handled.
• china: A draft law has been presented in China which provides that works created by AI may be protected by copyright if a natural person was significantly involved in the creation.

Challenges and Controversies

The issue of AI copyright is highly controversial and poses numerous challenges and controversy:

1) Property rights and remuneration

A central problem is the question of ownership rights to AI-generated works. Who should hold the rights to a work created by an AI? The developer of the AI, the user who operates the AI, or the AI itself? This question also has an impact on the remuneration of authors.

2) Quality and originality

Another point is the evaluation of the quality and originality of AI-generated works. Can such works be considered original if they are based on existing data and algorithms? And how should the quality of such works be assessed?

3) Legal responsibility

Who is legally responsible if an AI-generated work violates copyrights? This question is particularly relevant when it comes to using AI to create content based on copyrighted works.

Examples of AI-generated works and their legal treatment

In recent years, there have been several cases where AI-generated works have raised legal issues. Here are a few examples:

• music: AI systems such as AIVA and OpenAI's MuseNet can compose music independently. The question of whether these compositions are protected by copyright has not yet been clarified.
• arts: The portrait created by AI “Edmond de Belamy” was auctioned off at Christie's for over 400,000 US dollars in 2018. The legal question of who is entitled to copyright remains open.
• literature: AI systems such as GPT-3 can write convincing texts. Here, too, there is the question of copyright.

‍

The future of AI copyright

The rapid development of artificial intelligence requires an adjustment of the legal framework. Here are a few possible approaches that could be discussed in the future:

• Extension of copyright: One option would be to extend copyright so that AI-generated works also fall under it, provided that human involvement can be proven.
• New property rights: Alternatively, new intellectual property rights could be created specifically for AI-generated works.
• Clear guidelines: Clear guidelines could be developed which determine who holds rights to AI-generated works and to what extent.

‍

conclusion

The topic of AI copyright is complex and requires a careful consideration of various interests. Current regulations are lagging behind technological developments and there is an urgent need for action to create a clear legal framework. Companies and developers should be aware of legal uncertainties and take appropriate precautionary measures.

For more information and the latest developments in the area of AI and copyright, feel free to contact us. The KI Company provides you with non-binding advice and helps you to successfully implement your projects.

‍